VELOCITY · ELECTIONS · OPINION · OCTOBER 29, 2026 · UPDATED NOVEMBER 18, 2026
The Ballot Composition Project
The New York Times reports that Peltola aides and national Democrats recruited spoiler candidates in Alaska, including the second Dan Sullivan. Its key on-record source was fired by the campaign and has since tried to take her words back. Federal filings confirm one payment the story describes. Both the campaign and the party committee deny it.
OldGoat InTheHood · theyknewfirst.com · October 29, 2026
NYT REPORT OCT. 28FEC FILINGS READELECTION NOV. 3OPINION LABELED
HOW TO READ THIS. The recruiting story is REPORTED by the New York Times and has been denied by everyone it names who answered. The payments and ad spending are DOCUMENTED from the committees' own Federal Election Commission filings, which the Old Goat downloaded and read line by line. The court schedule is REPORTED from local coverage. The Old Goat's views are labeled OPINION. Five days ago the Old Goat called the Justice Department's Alaska suit one-sided. This dispatch applies the same lens to the other side.
Update · November 18, 2026 · Called
DOCUMENTED: The Associated Press called the Senate race for Mary Peltola on Nov. 17. She won 50.1% of first-choice votes to Sen. Dan Sullivan's 45.8%, so no ranked-choice tabulation was needed. About 99% of the vote was counted, and overseas ballots were due Nov. 18. She becomes the Senate's 56th Democrat and the first Alaska Native senator. Alaska Public Media →NBC →
REPORTED: Sullivan's campaign says it will not concede until certification, and the Justice Department says its investigation of the race is continuing. Certification is due Nov. 25. Democracy Docket →
Update · November 2, 2026
DOCUMENTED: U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the Justice Department's lawsuit on Sunday, Nov. 1, in a 20-page decision. She wrote that the government "provides no workable plan as to how it proposes to segregate ballots cast for Daniel J. Sullivan." The department filed a notice of appeal about an hour later, per Alaska Public Media.
REPORTED: NBC News, citing a U.S. official, says the department has issued at least three dozen new subpoenas and preservation requests, including to the Peltola campaign and to Dan J. Sullivan's campaign. Gov. Mike Dunleavy told the state Department of Public Safety to determine "whether criminal charges or civil action are warranted." House Oversight Chair James Comer asked Elisa Rios and Jerid Kurtz for transcribed interviews. Sen. Lisa Murkowski, who had supported Peltola's House runs and endorsed Sen. Sullivan this year, wrote that the reporting showed "a pattern of lies and coverups." Nobody has been charged. NBC reports that recruiting a candidate is not necessarily illegal, and the Peltola campaign and the DSCC still deny taking part.
DOCUMENTED, the same play from the other side: In Ohio, Enough Promises Ohio (C00962563) reported $1,743,982.01 supporting Greg Levy, a socialist candidate for Senate, and $883,334.76 opposing Sherrod Brown, in FEC lines dated Oct. 5 to Oct. 29. That is $2,627,316.77 in all. Its only receipt through Oct. 14 was $2.5 million from Conservative Americans PAC (C00855924), a super PAC whose largest donor this cycle in FEC data is American Prosperity Alliance. Money received after Oct. 14 is not due until the post-general report. Levy says his campaign is not behind the mailers and has condemned them, per Spectrum News. (FEC record)
INFERENCE, the Old Goat's: both parties are shopping for the same trick. Only one of them has the Justice Department answering it.
REPORTED, Nov. 1: Asked by CNN's Jake Tapper on "State of the Union" whether he would accept the result only if he won, Sen. Sullivan said: "No, I'm going to accept the election results." In the same interview he criticized the Peltola campaign over the reported recruiting of the second Sullivan (CNBC). INFERENCE: the candidate the Justice Department went to court to protect has now said he does not need its protection. CNBC →
REPORTED, Oct. 29: A lawsuit filed Oct. 29 says the Division of Elections failed to open 18 rural absentee in-person voting sites it had advertised, some in places with no other early voting nearby, and asks for an emergency order to open them. Alaska's News Source names the Alaska Democratic Party and rural legislators as plaintiffs; Democracy Docket names the Midnight Sun Independence Fund. The two reports may describe separate suits. No ruling had been reported by Nov. 2. Democracy Docket →Alaska's News Source →
Update · November 6, 2026 · The count, the post, and the money behind the Ohio trick
REPORTED, Alaska: As of Wednesday afternoon, Nov. 4, Mary Peltola had 102,962 first-choice votes (48 percent) and Sen. Dan S. Sullivan 102,325 (47.7 percent), a 637-vote gap. Gerald Heikes had 4,846 (2.3 percent) and Dan J. Sullivan 3,600 (1.7 percent). Tens of thousands of early, absentee and rural ballots were still uncounted. The state counts through Nov. 18, runs the ranked-choice tabulation that day, and certifies Nov. 25 (Anchorage Daily News). An Alaska Beacon analysis of ballot data found Sen. Sullivan would gain more than Peltola when Heikes and Dan J. Sullivan are eliminated, 2,728 votes to 1,868, though it did not include about 10,800 rural votes, which have leaned to Peltola. ADN →Alaska Beacon →
DOCUMENTED, from the site's Truth Social archive: On Nov. 5 the president posted: "The vote totals for the Fake Dan Sullivan, plus the other 'slug' that the Dems put on the Ballot, should be immediately given to the REAL Dan Sullivan, and the Election is over - He easily wins. There is no other fair solution!" The "slug" appears to be Heikes, a Republican, who told the ADN he was "irritated" by it and that FBI agents had served him a subpoena in the federal investigation. Post →
REPORTED, the appeal: The Justice Department's appeal of Judge Gleason's dismissal is before the Ninth Circuit with no expedited schedule: the department's opening brief is due Dec. 14 and the state's Jan. 11, after the Nov. 25 certification. Marc Elias: the department "filed an appeal to the Ninth Circuit but has taken no steps to seek immediate review or relief" (ADN).
INFERENCE: Alaska's ranked-choice system already moves votes from the last-place candidates to each voter's next choice. That is what happens on Nov. 18. What the post asks for is different: to hand one candidate the votes without asking what those voters ranked next.
REPORTED, Ohio: Sherrod Brown beat Sen. Jon Husted 2,301,042 to 2,077,748, 50 to 45.2 percent, with about 98 percent counted. Greg Levy, the socialist candidate Enough Promises Ohio spent $1.74 million promoting, drew 94,509 votes (2.1 percent), less than half of Brown's 223,294-vote margin. Libertarian Bill Redpath had 128,272 (unofficial returns via WTVC/13abc). Results →
DOCUMENTED, the money behind Enough Promises: Its only reported funder, Conservative Americans PAC (C00855924), has reported 12 gifts totaling $35,795,000 from American Prosperity Alliance of Reston, Virginia since March 2024, including $27.8 million on Dec. 23, 2025 (FEC Schedule A). American Prosperity Alliance is not an FEC committee. Its IRS filings, via ProPublica, show a 501(c)(4) incorporated in 2022 with Steve Stallmer as president; it reported $58.1 million in contributions in 2024. A 501(c)(4) does not have to name its donors, so the chain stops there. FEC →ProPublica →
Summary card of the facts below, with the same DOCUMENTED / REPORTED / INFERENCE labels.
What the Times Reported
REPORTED. On Oct. 28 the New York Times published what it calls a "ballot composition project." By its account, aides to Mary Peltola, the Democratic nominee for Senate in Alaska, began in the summer of 2025 to look for Alaskans named Dan Sullivan. The aim was a candidate who could draw votes from Sen. Dan S. Sullivan, the Republican incumbent, on Alaska's four-name general-election ballot. The Times says it interviewed 12 people and reviewed dozens of text messages. NYT (GV Wire) →
REPORTED. The central figure is Jerid Kurtz, a veteran Ohio Democratic operative. The Times says aides at the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee introduced him to the campaign as a specialist in ballot maneuvers. It reports that he found Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a retired teacher in Petersburg, who was willing to run. It says he traveled Alaska under the names "Zane" and "Jared" or "Jarid." Matthew Salisbury, a former House candidate in Anchorage, told the paper a man calling himself "Zane" urged him several times to run for Senate and offered outside spending; Salisbury later picked Kurtz out of a photo and did not run. Gerald Heikes, a drywall contractor from Palmer, said he was recruited this spring by a Midwestern man he met at a deli and is now on the ballot. David Leslie, a progressive Democrat who had a general-election spot, withdrew on Aug. 31 after calls from party figures including Kurtz, the Times says, which opened the spot Heikes filled. Kurtz did not respond to the paper.
REPORTED. The Times quotes texts between Anton McParland, then Peltola's chief of staff, and Andrew Piatt, the DSCC's director of campaigns. "Imagine if there was a MAGA party!" McParland wrote. "Smart," Piatt answered, then "Let's see." The paper says a lawyer at the Elias Law Group, which represents both the campaign and the DSCC, took part in talks about a new right-wing party, and that the idea died in May.
The Source Problem
REPORTED. The Times' main on-record source is Elisa Rios, Peltola's former campaign manager. The paper itself reports that the campaign fired her in an August staff shake-up and that she had planned a wrongful-termination suit, which she has not filed. It also reports that last week she took back her earlier statements and said she would not be a source for any story. The Times published anyway, saying it had never agreed to treat the interviews as off the record. Rios says Peltola was not directly involved but was "definitely aware."
That history is a reason to weigh her account carefully. It is not a reason to throw it out, because the story does not rest on her alone. Salisbury and Heikes spoke for themselves, and the paper quotes texts it says it reviewed. Part of the money trail can be checked, and the Old Goat checked it.
What the Filings Show
DOCUMENTED. The Times says Kurtz co-owns a firm called Wingspan Strategies and that 49th State PAC, a super PAC backing Peltola, paid it about $87,000 this fall. The PAC's own reports to the FEC show three payments to Wingspan Strategies LLC of Nashville, all labeled "Management Consulting": $59,327.46 on Sept. 22, then $13,383.18 and $15,000 on Oct. 14. That is $87,710.64. The PAC told the Times it never hired or paid Kurtz for services. The filings name the firm, not the man. Oct. Quarterly →Pre-General →
DOCUMENTED. 49th State PAC registered on Aug. 22 and reported $5,000,000.18 raised through Sept. 30. Nearly all of it came from two groups: $4.5 million from United Futures of Chicago ($2 million on Aug. 28, $2.5 million on Sept. 22) and $500,000 from Green Advocacy Project of Palo Alto on Sept. 9. The filings do not say who funds those groups.
DOCUMENTED. The Times says a super PAC called Alaska Values supports Heikes and that federal filings list radio time requested under the name of Jim Lottsfeldt, a consultant aligned with Peltola. Alaska Values PAC registered with the FEC on Sept. 2. Its treasurer is Thomas Datwyler of Hudson, Wis. It reported raising and spending nothing through Oct. 14. Between Oct. 15 and Oct. 26 its 24-hour reports list six amounts totaling $1,711,529.50: media buys, digital ads and texting through Liberty Buying Partners LLC of Cheyenne, Wyo.; $247,280.50 in direct mail through GROT LLC of Dover, Del.; and $100,000 in radio ads on Oct. 20 through Last Frontier Strategies LLC of Sheridan, Wyo. Each amount is entered twice, once as support for Heikes and once as opposition to Sen. Sullivan, so the running total on its own forms reads $3,423,059. The filings do not say whether that is one set of ads counted against two candidates. Who paid for any of it will not be public until the post-general report, due Dec. 3. 24-hour report →
REPORTED. Lottsfeldt told the Times he knew nothing about it, that the subject never came up at a March dinner with Peltola staff, and that his name may be on the filing by mistake.
The Denials
REPORTED. "The Alaskans for Mary campaign has no involvement with either Sullivan campaign and did not recruit any candidates into the race," the Peltola campaign said. The DSCC said it had "no involvement" in recruiting Sullivan "or any other Republican candidate." Dan J. Sullivan did not respond to the Times. He has said before that he ran on his own.
REPORTED, and not settled. Accounts of his registration differ. The Times says he switched from unaffiliated to Republican just before the filing deadline. NewsNation, citing state records, says he changed from Republican to undeclared when he asked for an absentee ballot for the August primary. The two accounts can both be true, one after the other. Either way, he appears on the ballot as "Daniel J. Sullivan Jr." with no party label. NewsNation →
What It Means for the Lawsuit
REPORTED. The Justice Department's suit to block certification if the senator narrowly loses was filed Oct. 22, six days before the story ran, so the suit was not built on it. The department has now told the court the report is a "change in circumstances" and says it will seek expedited discovery into what it calls a conspiracy, the Juneau Independent reports. U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason has fast-tracked the case. On Wednesday she let the League of Women Voters of Alaska and others intervene and said Peltola's campaign and the DSCC can press their motions to dismiss before the election. The department's response is due at 5 p.m. Thursday and the other side's on Friday. Juneau Independent →
REPORTED. The president posted that Peltola should be prosecuted and removed from the race. Rick Hasen of the Election Law Blog called the story a "political bombshell" if true but said it has no bearing on the lawsuit. Election lawyers quoted by the Times say ballot stacking is generally legal, and the paper notes both parties have used it in Alaska, citing a past House race in which the state GOP backed keeping a candidate on the ballot who was running from a New York prison.
The Old Goat's Two Cents
OPINION. Five days ago the Old Goat wrote that Alaskans can tell the two Sullivans apart. The Old Goat still thinks so. The senator drew more than 68,000 primary votes and the teacher 4,107, and the ballot marks which one is the incumbent. Nothing in the Times story changes those numbers.
OPINION. If the Times has it right, someone was counting on voters getting confused, and that is a dirty trick even where it is legal. The Old Goat would say the same if Republicans did it, and the Times says they have. Recruiting a man for his name, or a drywall contractor to split the other side, treats voters as marks. Democrats who complain about the Justice Department's suit should not be comfortable with this.
OPINION. Two things are true at once. The recruiting, if it happened, is hardball. The suit still asks a judge to set aside one result before a vote is counted. A campaign's trick is a matter for voters and, if any law was broken, for regulators. A federal order that holds one outcome in advance is a different thing, and the Old Goat's view of it has not changed.
Update · November 16, 2026 · The gap the lawsuit needed is gone
REPORTED, the count: In the Division of Elections' unofficial summary reported Nov. 13 and 14, Mary Peltola had 140,637 first-choice votes (49.94 percent) to Sen. Dan S. Sullivan's 129,424 (45.96 percent), a lead of about 11,200, with about 97 percent of ballots counted (Newsweek, Alaska Public Media). Her lead is now more than double Dan J. Sullivan's vote total. The Associated Press has not called the race. Because she is just under 50 percent, the ranked-choice tabulation on Nov. 18 decides it, and the state certifies Nov. 25. Alaska Public →ADN →
INFERENCE: The Justice Department's suit asked the court to block certification only if Peltola won by less than Dan J. Sullivan's vote. On these numbers that condition does not exist. The "give the votes to the REAL Dan Sullivan" post of Nov. 5 would not change the winner either. The department's appeal still has no expedited schedule, so the Ninth Circuit will not rule before certification.
DOCUMENTED, from the site's Truth Social archive: On Nov. 10 the president posted again: "Dan Sullivan PLUS Dan Sullivan wins the Alaska Election by thousands of votes. All votes going to the Fake Dan Sullivan, which was done solely for the purpose of fraud and confusion, should immediately be given to the Real Dan Sullivan." On the count above, the two Sullivans' first-choice votes together still trail Peltola's. Post →
REPORTED, still open: U.S. Attorney Michael Heyman's criminal investigation into how Dan J. Sullivan was recruited, and Gov. Dunleavy's state inquiry, continue. Nobody has been charged.
Ongoing Review
The Old Goat will revisit this dispatch from time to time to verify what's written here, and leaves it to the reader to draw their own conclusions from the information presented. Watch items: Judge Gleason's ruling on the motions to dismiss; whether the court grants the department discovery; any FEC complaint over coordination; Alaska Values PAC's post-general report, due Dec. 3; whether Rios files suit or speaks again; the Nov. 18 ranked-choice tabulation and Nov. 25 certification; the Heyman investigation.
One name, two Sullivans, and two sides playing for the confused voter.
Behind the curtain, no wizard to find. Just a thunder organ, a wallet, and scaffolding left behind.
The noise is the point. The scaffolding is the story.
Confirmed Sources
DOCUMENTED — 49th State PAC (C00959593), FEC Form 3X October Quarterly (filing 2025499) and Pre-General (filing 2032937): Wingspan Strategies LLC payments; receipts from United Futures and Green Advocacy Project. filing
DOCUMENTED — Alaska Values PAC (C00960633), FEC Form 1 (Sept. 2), October Quarterly and Pre-General (no activity), and 24-hour reports 2028601, 2028634, 2031079, 2033341, 2035194, 2042156 (Oct. 15–26). latest
REPORTED — New York Times (Kellen Browning), Oct. 28, 2026, read via GV Wire syndication. link
REPORTED — Juneau Independent, Oct. 28, 2026: DOJ "change in circumstances" filing, discovery, Gleason schedule, Hasen quote. link