The Question
House Democrats nominated Hakeem Jeffries for speaker on Nov. 18 by 251 to 11 in a secret ballot. Senate Democrats choose between Chuck Schumer and Chris Van Hollen on Dec. 1. A column now circulating among Democrats, unattributed in the copy the Old Goat received, argues that Jeffries, Schumer and Trump form a New York trifecta, "drenched in AIPAC and Big Tech money," and that Democratic voters were handed "controlled opposition." CNN →
Anger like that is a lead, not a finding. The record that can test it is public: how the leaders voted, and what the Federal Election Commission shows about who paid them. The Old Goat ran the same checks on Van Hollen, the challenger, and on the two Republican leaders, John Thune and Jim Jordan, so the numbers have something to be compared against.
How They Voted
DOCUMENTED, from the Senate and House Clerk roll-call records, read Nov. 18. In the Senate, a "discharge" motion is how a senator forces a floor vote on blocking an arms sale. In the House, the test came as an amendment to cut aid in a spending bill.
| Senate vote (date, roll call) | Result | Schumer | Van Hollen | Thune |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Block arms sales to Israel, S.J.Res. 33 and 26 (Apr. 3 2025, #165, #166) | 15–82, 15–83 | Nay, Nay | Yea, Yea | Nay, Nay |
| Block arms sales to Israel, S.J.Res. 41 and 34 (July 30 2025, #454, #455) | 27–70, 24–73 | Nay, Nay | Yea, Yea | Nay, Nay |
| Block arms sales to Israel, S.J.Res. 32 and 138 (Apr. 15 2026, #80, #81) | 40–59, 36–63 | Nay, Nay | Yea, Yea | Nay, Nay |
| Request Israel's human-rights record under Sec. 502B, S.Res. 852 (Sept. 29 2026, #252) | 47–51 | Yea | Yea | Nay |
| Iran war powers, S.J.Res. 59 (June 27 2025, #328) | 47–53 | Yea | Yea | Nay |
| Iran war powers, all 14 Senate votes in 2026 (#46, #58, #69, #79, #88, #113, #118, #129, #174, #184, #192, #207, #216, #244) | two passed (#129, #184) | Yea on all | Yea on all | Nay on all |
| GENIUS Act stablecoin bill, passage (June 17 2025, #318) | 68–30 | Nay | Nay | Yea |
| CLARITY Act, cloture to proceed (Sept. 15 2026, #234) The Missing Clause → | 49–50 | Nay | Nay | Yea |
| House vote (date, roll call) | Result | Jeffries | Jordan |
|---|---|---|---|
| Massie amendment cutting $3.3B in security aid to Israel, H.R. 8595 (July 15 2026, #243). Democrats split 103 yes, 98 no, 10 present. | 104–314 | No | No |
| Iran war powers: H.Con.Res. 86 (June 3, #199), H.Con.Res. 89 (July 23, #282), H.Con.Res. 93 (Sept. 15, #307), all 2026 | all three passed | Yea on all | Nay on all |
| Table the impeachment of President Trump, H.Res. 1486 (Sept. 15 2026, #298). Democrats: 18 to table, 147 against, 46 present. | 232–147 | Present | Yea |
| Refer Hegseth impeachment to committee, H.Res. 1655 (Nov. 10 2026, #317) | 211–204 | Nay (against burying it) | Yea |
| CLARITY Act, passage (July 17 2025, #199) | 294–134 | Nay | Yea |
| GENIUS Act, passage (July 17 2025, #200) | 308–122 | Yea | Yea |
Senate votes 2026 → Senate votes 2025 → House #243 → House #298 → House #317 → House #199 (2025) →
What in the record supports the column. On every vote to block weapons for Israel, six in all over two years, Schumer voted the same way as Thune, the Republican leader, and the other way from Van Hollen. When the House voted in July on cutting Israel's security aid, more House Democrats voted yes than no, and Jeffries voted no, calling the amendment "overly broad." In September, when a Democrat forced a vote on impeaching the president, Jeffries voted present while 147 Democrats voted to keep it alive. On the money side, he took more earmarked AIPAC donor money than the other four leaders combined in 2024 and 2026. He also met privately with Kushner in August. Orbit → Forecast →
What cuts against it. On the Iran war, both men voted to end it every time it reached the floor: Schumer 15 times in the Senate over two years and Jeffries three times in the House. Schumer voted no on both crypto bills, and Jeffries voted no on the market-structure bill. Schumer voted for the Sept. 29 resolution asking for Israel's human-rights record. Jeffries voted against burying the Hegseth impeachment on Nov. 10.
OPINION. The Old Goat's read: the line between the leaders and the base is not on the war or on crypto. It is on Israel, and on how hard to fight Trump in the House. That is what the Dec. 1 race and the Jan. 3 vote are about. The reader can weigh the rest.
Who Paid Them
DOCUMENTED, from the AIPAC PAC's own filings with the FEC (committee C00797670, Schedule B, pulled Nov. 18). The PAC moved money two ways. Direct means a contribution from the PAC's own account. Earmarked means individual donors wrote checks that the PAC collected and passed to the campaign with each donor's name attached. The two are not the same thing and are not added together here.
| Recipient committee | Cycle | Direct from the PAC | Earmarked donor money (checks) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jeffries for Congress | 2022 | $10,000 | $62,895 (62) |
| Jeffries for Congress | 2024 | $7,500 + $2,500 in-kind | $921,860 (703) |
| Jeffries Majority Fund | 2024 | none | $91,350 (36) |
| Jeffries for Congress | 2026 | none | $22,096 (50) |
| Jeffries Victory Fund | 2026 | none | $250,000 (20) |
| Jeffries Battleground Protection Fund | 2026 | none | $149,300 (2 checks, one donor) |
| Friends of Schumer | 2022 | $7,900 | $93,170 (93) |
| Friends of Schumer | 2024, 2026 | none | none |
| Van Hollen for Senate | 2022–2026 | none | none |
| Friends of John Thune | 2022 | $7,900 | $164,830 (152) |
| Jim Jordan for Congress | 2022 | $7,900 | $29,269 (21) |
| Jim Jordan for Congress | 2024 | $10,000 | $67,093 (65) |
| Jim Jordan for Congress | 2026 | $10,000 | $164,037 (110) |
Figures are the FEC's processed data through the latest reports, net of refunds, and can change if a report is amended. They cover every committee carrying each leader's name that received AIPAC PAC money. Jeffries' three committees took $421,396 in earmarked money in the 2026 cycle; Sludge's count of more than $427,000 is close and may include later filings. Schumer's own committee has had no AIPAC PAC money since 2022. He is next on the ballot in 2028. FEC data →
What the table shows. Jeffries is the largest earmark recipient of the five by far: more than $1 million in 2024 and $421,396 so far in 2026, including $149,300 in two checks from one donor to his Battleground Protection Fund in May. In 2022 Thune drew more earmarked AIPAC money than Schumer. Jordan's 2026 total is less than half of Jeffries'. Van Hollen took none. The PAC's direct gifts were small and nearly identical across the parties. Donors tab →
The super PAC is not in it. AIPAC's super PAC, the United Democracy Project, has reported no independent spending for or against any of the five in FEC data. That says less than it seems: Schumer, Van Hollen and Thune are not on the ballot again until 2028, and Jeffries and Jordan have safe seats. The two big crypto super PACs, Fairshake and Protect Progress, have reported none for or against any of them either. UDP filings →
The model is changing. AIPAC announced on Oct. 21 that it will stop endorsing candidates, stop direct PAC contributions and stop earmarking after the midterms. The super PAC continues, and the group is asking members to give to candidates directly, which the FEC reports will show only by donor name, not by any AIPAC label. NPR →
Tech money. REPORTED: In 2016, Schumer took about $38,900 from people tied to Facebook, more than any other senator and second only to Hillary Clinton, by OpenSecrets' count. His daughter Jessica Schumer, Amazon's longest-serving New York lobbyist, left in September 2026 to run OpenAI's Northeast policy and partnerships (Axios). The Old Goat has not yet tallied tech, crypto and defense donors by employer from the FEC filings for all five, and will add that table when it is checked. RCI → Axios →
The Column, Graded
The Old Goat checked the column's factual claims one at a time. Its adjectives are its own and are not graded. The tally and the table follow.
Tally: 17 claims checked. 12 hold (some with a caveat), 2 need context, 3 are wrong or could not be found.
| The column says | The record | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Schumer attended Roy Cohn's birthday party at Studio 54. | The Village Voice listed him as a guest at Cohn's party there in February 1979, as a young Brooklyn assemblyman who said he came as a columnist's date. No source the Old Goat found puts Trump at that party. | HOLDS for Schumer; not shown for Trump |
| Schumer says God made him a "guardian of Israel." | He has said for years that his name comes from shomer, Hebrew for guardian, and that God gave it to him, including in a 2010 radio interview. The "keep the left pro-Israel" line is attributed to a 2025 Times interview the Old Goat has seen only quoted secondhand. | HOLDS; second quote unconfirmed |
| Trump called himself "King of Israel" and "the Second Coming of God." | On Aug. 21, 2019 he tweeted those words, quoting the radio host Wayne Allyn Root, who said Israeli Jews love him "like he is the King of Israel" and "the second coming of God." | HOLDS, with context: he was quoting someone |
| Jeffries said "Israel today, Israel tomorrow, Israel forever!" in 2014. | The Old Goat found no record of the remark. | NOT FOUND |
| Pelosi said in December 2018 that if the Capitol crumbled, the commitment to Israel would remain. | She said it on stage with Haim Saban at the Israeli-American Council conference in Florida on Dec. 2, 2018, where Schumer also spoke; the IAC is an Israeli-American group. The wording comes from secondhand accounts. | HOLDS |
| After Jan. 6, Pelosi recited "I have no other country," a poem about Israel. | She cited the Ehud Manor poem in her floor remarks in January 2021. Isaac Herzog had given it to her in 2016. | HOLDS |
| Netanyahu stayed at the Kushners' home in the 1980s. | Kushner's memoir says Netanyahu slept in his bedroom while Jared slept in the basement. The Forward's excerpts place the visit in the early 2000s, not the 1980s. | HOLDS; date in doubt |
| Jeffries calls Jerusalem "New York City's sixth borough." | He has used the phrase since at least 2020, per City & State. | HOLDS |
| Jeffries met Kushner privately in August 2026 to discuss affordability. | The Times first reported it. Jeffries said Kushner asked for the meeting and that they discussed affordability. The criticism came mainly from Democrats and the left. | HOLDS |
| Rep.-elect Don Leonard says senior Democrats threatened him unless he backed Jeffries. | Leonard said so on video. He has not named anyone, caucus chair Pete Aguilar dismissed it, and nobody has confirmed it. His stated conditions were movement on Gaza and campaign finance. | HOLDS as his claim; unconfirmed |
| Mike Johnson became speaker in 2020 and called a Temple Mount visit "the fulfillment of a biblical prophecy." | Johnson became speaker in October 2023. He did visit the Temple Mount. The Old Goat found no source for the quote. | WRONG date; quote not found |
| Jim Jordan became "minority Speaker" in November 2026. | There is no such post. House Republicans elected him their leader, 106–73, on Nov. 10. | WRONG title |
| On Sept. 11, 2024, Jeffries introduced Johnson at a Chabad fundraiser where Johnson got a menorah made from rockets, and Jeffries invoked Amalek. | At the American Friends of Lubavitch gala, Jeffries introduced Johnson, called the commitment to Israel's security "ironclad and unbreakable," and cited that week's Torah portion on remembering Amalek. Reports describe the menorah as made from Hamas rockets or Iron Dome shrapnel. | HOLDS; "genocidal" is the column's word |
| In 2025 Jeffries received the same award, shared with Alex Karp. | Karp was honored at the Sept. 16, 2025 Lamplighter gala. Jeffries was honored at a reception beforehand; accounts differ on whether it was the same award. | CONTEXT |
| Trump and Lutnick decided to recruit Musk after praying at Chabad headquarters. | Lutnick says that on the drive back from the Lubavitcher Rebbe's grave in Queens on Oct. 7, 2024, he told Trump he would recruit Musk. The grave is not the Brooklyn headquarters. | HOLDS, wrong place |
| In 2016 Schumer got more money from Facebook employees than any member of Congress. | More than any other senator; second overall to Hillary Clinton (about $38,900, OpenSecrets). | CONTEXT |
| One Schumer daughter left Amazon's lobbying team in September 2026 for OpenAI. | Axios reported the hire Sept. 5, 2026. | HOLDS |
What the Old Goat Will Not Repeat
OPINION. The column says the three men "represent Israel," calls the country "a subsidiary of Israel," asks where Jeffries' loyalty "lies," treats Chabad as a crime network and calls New York "a transnational mafia hub." Those lines are not checkable claims. They follow an old pattern that questions a public official's loyalty because of a country or a faith, and the record does not need them. Schumer voted to end the U.S. war on Iran every time it came to the Senate floor. The money in the filings arrived through a registered lobbying group's PAC and through donors who chose to give, and those donors have many faiths and none. The case against the leadership is the votes and the filings. It is strong enough to stand without the rest.
What to Watch
- Dec. 1: Senate Democrats vote on Schumer or Van Hollen by secret ballot.
- Dec. 3: post-general FEC reports, the last ones that can show AIPAC PAC earmarks under its old practice.
- Jan. 3: the House floor vote for speaker, when Jeffries needs a majority of members present.
- Whether the money that used to move through the AIPAC PAC shows up as direct individual gifts instead.